A shed isn’t just a backyard structure—it’s an extension of your home and a long-term investment in your property. Whether you’re looking for more storage, a garden workspace, or a backyard retreat, the structure you choose should offer both function and durability. Many homeowners are drawn to the low price tags on big box store sheds, but what you save upfront often leads to headaches later.
This blog will break down the real differences between big box store sheds and custom-built structures. From construction quality to long-term value, we’ll show you what you’re truly getting with each option—and why a custom shed from North Mountain Structures is the better choice for lasting performance and peace of mind.
Big box store sheds are enticing because of their lower initial price. For around $1,500–$2,500, you can walk away with a ready-to-assemble shed. That price is tough to beat, especially for homeowners looking for a quick solution.
Sheds from stores like Home Depot, Lowe’s, and Walmart are easy to find and often available for same-day pickup or fast delivery. Many customers appreciate the simplicity of ordering online or in-store and having a shed delivered to their driveway within days.
Most big box stores offer a limited selection of styles and sizes. If you’re okay with generic options, it might feel like a quick win. No designing, no decisions—just choose and go.
Marketing materials promise “easy assembly,” making it seem like a shed from a big retailer is a no-fuss solution. It feels like a straightforward path to solving your storage problem.
Mass-produced sheds often use:
These materials may be cheaper, but they aren’t built to withstand the elements. Rain, snow, and humidity can break them down fast.
These sheds are manufactured at scale, which leaves little room for quality control. As a result:
Because of the materials and construction shortcuts, big box sheds typically last 3 to 7 years before needing significant repairs or complete replacement. That “cheap” shed ends up costing more.
Despite claims of “easy setup,” customer reviews tell a different story. Many users face:
Some end up hiring professionals to finish the job—eliminating the cost advantage entirely.
With a custom shed, you choose:
You get functionality that matches your lifestyle.
At North Mountain Structures, we use:
These materials resist rot, warping, and wear—ensuring your shed stands strong year after year.
Custom sheds are built by skilled hands, not machines. Each piece is measured, cut, and assembled with care. This attention to detail means better:
We build with Pennsylvania’s weather in mind. That means ventilated roofs, moisture barriers, and features that protect against snow, heat, and rain.
Let’s look at real numbers. Here’s a side-by-side comparison of total shed ownership cost over 10 years:
Observations:
Big box sheds may come with limited warranties (usually 1 year or less). North Mountain Structures offers strong warranties that cover materials and workmanship for much longer—because we trust what we build.
A well-built shed adds value to your property. It can improve resale appeal and even count toward assessed value in some areas.
You bought a prefab plastic shed. Within 18 months, the roof sagged and water seeped in. You eventually tore it down and replaced it with a 10×14 A-frame from us. Now you have a shed that’s dry, durable, and beautiful.
| Feature | Big Box Shed | North Mountain Custom Shed |
|---|---|---|
| Wall Framing | 2×3 or thinner studs | 2×4 (or even 2×6) framing |
| Floor | Thin OSB or particle | 3/4″ treated plywood |
| Siding | Pressboard or plastic | SmartSide or LP wood siding |
| Roofing | Lightweight panels | Architectural shingles |
What are you storing? How will you use the shed?
Knowing this will shape your layout and features.
Compare specs:
Instead of “How much is it?”, ask:
Local businesses like North Mountain Structures offer personalized service, better construction, and support you won’t get from a big retailer.
Big box store sheds might look good on paper, but they’re often a short-term solution that leads to long-term frustration. Custom-built sheds provide superior value, longevity, and style.
At North Mountain Structures, we use real wood, real craftsmanship, and build for real life. Don’t just store your stuff—protect it in a structure made to last.
Ready to upgrade from prefab to premium?
Contact us today to get a quote and start building a shed that’s worth every penny.
When many homeowners think about outdoor buildings, they picture sheds full of lawn gear, garages that only see action in winter, or a chicken coop
When most people think about a greenhouse, they picture springtime—rows of tiny seedlings waiting to be transplanted into the garden. But the reality is a
If you’re like most homeowners, your lawn mower, weed trimmers, garden tools, and bags of seed are probably packed somewhere in a cluttered garage —
Raising backyard chickens is both rewarding and practical — but making sure they have enough space is one of the most important parts of keeping
If you’re like most parents, adding a backyard playset sounds like a dream: the kids get hours of screen-free fun, you get a few precious
If you’re in need of extra storage space, a home office, or a workshop, a storage shed can be a practical solution. At North Mountain